Why Are Goldfish So Dirty? {Why So Much Ammonia?}

Goldfish often appear dirty and many people wonder why are goldfish so dirty?

In this article, we will explore the reasons behind their perceived dirtiness. From their natural behaviors to their biology, several factors contribute to the appearance of goldfish being dirty.

By understanding these factors, we can better care for our goldfish and maintain a cleaner and healthier environment for them.

Why Are Goldfish So Dirty?

Goldfish are often associated with being “dirty” due to several reasons related to their natural behaviors and care requirements.

Here are some factors that contribute to this perception:

  1. Waste Production: Goldfish produce a significant amount of waste, mainly in the form of ammonia released through their gills and excrement. This waste can accumulate in the tank and affect water quality if not properly managed.
  2. Constant Eating: Goldfish have voracious appetites and are known to constantly search for food. This behavior leads to them producing more waste as a byproduct of their digestion.
  3. Foraging Behavior: Goldfish are natural foragers, and they tend to stir up the substrate in search of food. This can cause debris and sediment to become suspended in the water, making it appear cloudy or dirty.
  4. Need for Spacious Tanks: Goldfish require spacious aquariums with adequate filtration to accommodate their size and waste production. Insufficient tank size or insufficient filtration can lead to poor water quality and a dirty tank.

To maintain a cleaner and healthier environment for goldfish, it is important to provide a properly sized tank, effective filtration, regular water changes, and a balanced feeding regimen.

Why Do Goldfish Produce a Lot of Waste?

Goldfish are known to produce a significant amount of waste due to their natural biology and feeding habits.

Here’s why:

  1. Physiological Factors: Goldfish have a relatively inefficient digestive system, which means they produce more waste compared to some other fish species.
  2. Constant Eating: Goldfish have a strong appetite and are always searching for food. Their continuous eating leads to increased waste production.
  3. High Metabolism: Goldfish have a fast metabolic rate, requiring them to consume more food. This metabolic activity results in more waste being generated.

Can Overfeeding Contribute to Goldfish Being Dirty?

Yes, overfeeding can contribute to goldfish appearing dirty. Here are some reasons:

  1. Feed goldfish in appropriate quantities: Follow recommended feeding guidelines and monitor the amount of food consumed by your goldfish.
  2. Use sinking pellets: Opt for sinking pellets that are easier for goldfish to consume, reducing the chances of excess food sinking to the bottom.
  3. Remove uneaten food: If there is any leftover food after feeding, promptly remove it from the tank to prevent decomposition and water quality issues.
  4. Establish a feeding schedule: Feed goldfish in regular intervals rather than continuously throughout the day, allowing them to consume the food offered without excess leftovers.

How Does Poor Tank Filtration Contribute to Goldfish Being Dirty?

Poor tank filtration can significantly impact the cleanliness of a goldfish tank. Here’s how:

Insufficient Waste Removal: Inadequate filtration systems fail to effectively remove waste particles, uneaten food, and debris from the water. This accumulation of waste contributes to the dirty appearance of the tank.

Water Quality Issues: Inadequate filtration hinders the removal of harmful substances, such as ammonia and nitrites, which can build up in the water.

These pollutants not only affect the health of goldfish but also contribute to a dirty and cloudy tank.

Can Goldfish Stir Up Sediment and Make the Tank Look Dirty?

Yes, goldfish can stir up sediment in the tank, making it appear dirty. This is what happens:

  1. Foraging Behavior: Goldfish are natural foragers and tend to sift through the substrate in search of food. This activity can disturb the sediment, causing it to become suspended in the water column and giving the tank a dirty appearance.
  2. Rooting for Food: Goldfish may dig into the substrate or uproot plants while foraging. This disturbance releases particles into the water, further contributing to the cloudiness and dirtiness of the tank.

To maintain a cleaner tank, it is essential to provide adequate filtration, feed goldfish in appropriate quantities, and perform regular water changes.

Proper tank maintenance, including removing uneaten food and debris, helps promote a healthier and visually cleaner environment for goldfish.

YouTube video

Why Is My Goldfish Tank Cloudy After One Day?

It can be concerning to see a cloudy goldfish tank shortly after setting it up. Here are some possible reasons for the cloudiness:

  1. New Tank Syndrome: Cloudiness in a newly set up goldfish tank is often a result of New Tank Syndrome. During the initial stages, beneficial bacteria responsible for breaking down waste may not have established sufficiently. This leads to an imbalance in the tank’s ecosystem, resulting in cloudiness.
  2. Poor Filtration: Insufficient filtration or improper setup of the filter can contribute to cloudy water. Inadequate filtration may not effectively remove waste, excess food, or other particles, causing the water to appear cloudy.
  3. Overfeeding: Overfeeding goldfish can lead to excess food sinking to the bottom and decomposing. The decomposition process releases organic matter that clouds the water.
  4. Algae Bloom: If the tank receives excessive light or is exposed to direct sunlight, it can trigger an algae bloom. Algae multiply rapidly, turning the water green and causing cloudiness.

To address cloudy water:

  • Ensure proper filtration and allow time for the tank to establish beneficial bacteria.
  • Avoid overfeeding and remove any uneaten food promptly.
  • Monitor light exposure and adjust accordingly to prevent algae growth.

Perform partial water changes to improve water quality.
By addressing these potential causes, you can improve water clarity and maintain a healthy environment for your goldfish.

Do Goldfish Give off a Lot of Ammonia?

Yes, goldfish do produce a significant amount of ammonia as part of their natural biological processes. Check out these factors:

  • Gills: Goldfish excrete ammonia through their gills as a waste product of their respiration. Ammonia is released when goldfish extract oxygen from the water.
  • Waste: Goldfish excrete ammonia through their waste, including urine and feces. The more goldfish in a tank or the larger the goldfish, the greater the amount of waste and ammonia produced.
  • Feeding Habits: Goldfish are voracious eaters and have a fast metabolism. This results in increased food consumption and waste production, including ammonia.

Ammonia is toxic to goldfish and other aquatic organisms. In high concentrations, it can harm fish by causing stress, damaging their gills, and compromising their overall health.

It is essential to monitor and control ammonia levels in the tank to ensure a safe and healthy environment for goldfish.

How to minimize ammonia levels

  • Adequate Filtration: Use a reliable filtration system to remove waste and toxins, including ammonia, from the water.
  • Regular Water Changes: Perform routine water changes to dilute and remove accumulated ammonia and other pollutants.
  • Avoid Overstocking: Avoid overcrowding the tank to prevent excessive ammonia production from fish waste.

By maintaining proper tank filtration, performing regular water changes, and practicing responsible fishkeeping, you can help keep ammonia levels in check and promote a healthy environment for your goldfish.


The perceived dirtiness of goldfish can be attributed to various factors, including their high waste production, foraging behavior, and tank maintenance practices.

By addressing these factors and implementing proper care techniques such as regular tank cleaning, air pump, adequate filtration, and controlled feeding, it is possible to reduce the dirtiness associated with goldfish.

Creating a clean and well-maintained environment not only enhances the aesthetic appeal of the tank but also promotes the overall health and well-being of our beloved goldfish


Thanks for visiting HelpUsFish.com for this article. Check out our home page and search bar with hundreds of aquatic or marine life articles to choose from. Bye for now!

Brian Arial

Brian Arial has kept fish for leisure and worked with fish stores for most of his life. He enjoys writing and caring for aquariums and ponds.