How Long Can a Fish Survive in a Bag


Are you wondering how long you can keep your fish in a bag? Do you know keeping fish for too long in the bag can cause the fish to die? Read on to learn how long you can keep a fish in a tank, and the right measures to put in place.

A fish can stay comfortable in a bag for about 7 to 9 hours before it starts feeling stressed. After that, you will have to remove the fish from the bag to provide it with comfort. Some people add oxygen to the bag allowing the fish to stay alive for about 48 hours.

How Long Can I Leave Fish in a Bag?

You can leave your fish in a bag for about 7 to 9 hours without any issue. However, a bag is not the ideal home for a fish, so you need to move it out of the bag as soon as you can. The bag is usually smaller than the tank, containing a lesser amount of water, oxygen, and other resources.

Putting the fish in the bag can cause the fish to feel uncomfortable and get stressed out. In addition, the small size of the bag can cramp them and cause them to develop certain problems. It is one of the reasons they can’t last long in a bag.

Another reason you need to remove the fish from the bag as soon as you can is because of the limited amount of oxygen in the bag. The bag does not contain much water, therefore containing little oxygen. When the fish use up all the oxygen in the water, they start to die.

Some people add more oxygen to the bag to ensure the fish last longer in the bag. Adding oxygen to the bag can cause the fish to live for about 48 hours. You will need to remove the fish from the bag when the time elapses.

There are also other resources missing in the bag. These resources help keep the fish alive and healthy. You also cannot have aquatic plants in a bag, which is essential to the fish’s survival. You can also not have some essential device in a bag.

Devices like a filter, lighting, etc., in a bag; you can only have them in a tank. You only need to keep a fish in the bag for a little while before transferring it to the tank; it isn’t the fish’s home.

YouTube video

Can Fish Suffocate in Bags?

Fish can suffocate in bags and will do that faster in a sealed one. It is because the bag has little capacity and contains little oxygen. When the fish uses up the oxygen in the bag, it starts to suffocate and eventually dies.

You shouldn’t fill the water in the bag to the brim to provide more time for your fish. You can also add oxygen to the bag to replenish the loss of oxygen. It can help keep the fish alive for about 48 to 72 hours.

All these will only buy time for the fish. If you do not take the right step, your fish will eventually suffocate and die. You need to transfer the fish to a tank to get enough oxygen for its survival.

Keeping a fish in the bag should not belong as the bag only serves as an emergency alternative. You cannot make the bag the fish’s home. The fish will also not experience adequate growth in a bag.

The fish can also develop several complications when kept in a bag. The bag will also not contain the needed devices like the filter. Without the filter in the bag, it is difficult to aerate the water, causing a limited amount of oxygen, hence suffocation and death.

The absence of a filter can also cause the buildup of toxic material in the bag. These toxic materials can affect your fish and cause its death. The water will also get dirty easily as there is no filter to remove debris and dirt.

You can avoid this problem a bit by performing frequent water changes. However, changing the water in a bag can hurt, stress, or worse, kill the fish.

How Long Does It Take for a Fish to Suffocate?

The time it takes for a fish to suffocate and die varies according to species. On average, it takes about two days for a fish to suffocate and die. However, fish species that evolved from a low-oxygen environment tend to stay alive much longer before dying.

These fish can take about 2 to 4 days before they suffocate and die. Fish tend to lose consciousness and die faster at a higher temperature. It will only occur in still water without an air pump or filter.

If there is enough water movement by various devices like air stones, air pump, filters, etc., your fish will not have any reason to suffocate. It is because the water movement will cause the water to become aerated and filled with oxygen.

Frequent water can also save the fish from suffocating and dying. When there is water movement, there will be enough oxygen for the fish to use. Suffocation occurs when there is enough or any oxygen for the fish to breathe.

So, with enough oxygen in the tank, you can save your fish from suffocation, hence, death. You only have to provide the needed conditions for this to occur.

How Long Can a Fish Survive Without a Filter?

A fish can survive for about 3 to 7 days without a filter. The fish can live even longer if other conditions are intact. The filter performs a great function of filtering waste and debris from entering the tank.

It also helps get rid of toxic waste of ammonia and nitrates from the tank. Filters also help keep the tank aerated and full of oxygen. Without the filter, you might not be able to get this done, causing the risk of hazard for your fish.

With other conditions in place, your fish can survive for days without a filter. After that, however, you will have to perform frequent water changes. Nevertheless, it will help keep your fish alive much longer.


A fish can survive in a bag, but not for long. It will only take a matter of hours before it dies. So you need to get the fish in a tank as soon as you can.

John Brandon

John has kept fish all his life (since he was about 5). He started with keeping guppies and fell in love with fish keeping almost straight away. That was 40 odd years ago. These days John still keeps fish and currently has two large tanks where he keeps many different types of fish such as Angelfish, Neon Tetras, Goldfish, Guppies and many more.

Recent Posts

How Long Can Beneficial Bacteria Su...
How Long Can Beneficial Bacteria Survive Without Fish?